top of page

How to Compare Two Health Plans in Five Minutes

4 days ago
2 min read

At open enrollment, the plan with the lower paycheck deduction can look like the obvious choice. But the premium is only one piece of what a plan costs you over a year. Here's a quick method for comparing two plans, so you're looking at the whole picture.

Step 1: Total Up the Yearly Premium

Take the amount taken from each paycheck for that plan and multiply it by the number of pay periods in a year. That's your yearly premium. If you're covering a spouse or children, use the paycheck amount for your coverage tier. Employers typically cover part of the employee's premium, and employees often pay most or all of the dependents' share, though plans vary.

Step 2: Add What You'd Pay When You Use Care

For each plan, find four numbers on the plan summary:

  • The deductible: what you pay before the plan starts sharing costs.

  • Coinsurance or copays: your share after the deductible, or a flat amount per visit.

  • The out-of-pocket maximum: the most you'd pay in a year for covered in-network care. It doesn't include your premium.

  • Any employer HSA contribution, if the plan is HSA-eligible. That money offsets your costs.

Step 3: Check the Worst Case

For covered in-network care, your worst-case year is your yearly premium plus the out-of-pocket maximum. For 2027 plan years, the federal cap on that maximum is $12,000 for one person, and many plans set it lower. Knowing the worst case for each plan tells you what each one could cost on its toughest year.

A Quick Example

Here are two made-up plans. Both have 20% coinsurance, and we'll ignore copays and assume all care is in network to keep it simple.

  • Plan A: $150 a month, $2,000 deductible, $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum.

  • Plan B: $240 a month, $500 deductible, $4,000 out-of-pocket maximum.

Their yearly premiums are $1,800 and $2,880. Add what each plan costs you in three different years:

  • A light year ($1,000 of care): Plan A totals $2,800. Plan B totals $3,480.

  • A moderate year ($5,000 of care): Plan A totals $4,400. Plan B totals $4,280.

  • A big year ($25,000 of care): Plan A totals $7,800. Plan B totals $6,880.

The plan with the lower premium wins in a light year and loses in a big one. Neither plan is better in every situation. Which is right depends on how much care you expect to use. (These numbers are illustrative, not real plans.)

Step 4: Check What the Numbers Don't Show

Cost isn't everything. Make sure your doctors are in the plan's network and your prescriptions are on its drug list. A cheaper plan that doesn't cover your care isn't cheaper.

Final Thoughts

Five minutes of math can change which plan looks like the better deal. If you'd like help comparing the plans your employer offers, send us a message.

Comments


Tell us a bit about your business and we'll show you what white-glove benefits support actually looks like.

Follow Us

Frequently asked questions

Service 1st Benefits
Norman, Oklahoma
(405) 561-1514

Serving Norman, Oklahoma City, Edmond, Moore, Midwest City, and the greater OKC metro area.

bottom of page